IPE/BC is an independent, non-partisan organization, however we recognize that IPE/BC Associates and guest authors hold a range of views and interests relative to public schools, education issues, and the political landscape in BC. Perspectives is an opportunity for Associates and others to share their ideas in short, accessible essays.
You can’t mandate what matters
November 19, 2026
by Rick Fabbro
Our newly elected government in BC indicates that it wishes to mandate the daily singing of “O Canada” in our schools. They claim their goal is to instill pride in our nation. There has been an immediate and enthusiastic response on social media. I am not against the singing of our anthem, nor am I against feeling pride in Canada. I think it is important to analyze whether the intended goal will be achieved by the method proposed.
National pride is earned by the actions of our institutions and citizens, not by forced singing. Singing the national anthem every day does not create genuine national pride. Patriotism cannot be mandated or measured by how often we stand and sing. True national pride comes not from the words we sing (and in my case – off-key), but from the values we collectively share and live.
I have witnessed impromptu renditions of O Canada that have truly warmed my heart. Those moments are powerful precisely because they are genuine, voluntary expressions of shared pride and belonging, not obligatory rituals.
A quick look at history and current situations around the world shows that authoritarian and fascist regimes have often relied on compulsory displays of patriotism. When national pride becomes an obligation rather than a feeling, we risk teaching obedience instead of fostering genuine love of country.
True national pride comes from how governments and society treat their citizens, especially the most vulnerable. How a country and its citizenry ensure that seniors live with dignity, children grow up without poverty, families have secure housing, and everyone is treated with compassion, equality, and respect goes much further in nurturing pride in one’s country than performative renditions of an anthem.
There are better options for how to teach the anthem and promote good feelings about our country. I think it is much better to put the learning into context. Just off the top of my head, here is an example of a lesson: Listen to national anthems of 5 countries. Have a
general discussion about why countries have national anthems. Do all countries have words to the music? What are common themes in the lyrics? What makes one proud of their country? I am sure the Charter of Rights would come up. An assignment could be:
-search the internet for 3 examples where someone, or some organization, has acted in a way that exemplifies the Charter of Rights,
-find 2 examples where it is unclear and more information is needed, and
-find 1 example where the action was contrary to the Charter of Rights.
Then, at maybe three assemblies during the year, the school highlights an exemplary Canadian and sings the anthem.
When we stand on guard – all of us – let’s stand on guard for the dignity of every Canadian, regardless of ethnicity, gender, orientation, or social status. I would not want to live anywhere else than in Canada. Having said that, I recognize that Canada is still a work in progress. If we want our children to be proud of our country, let’s keep working on building a country worthy of their pride. I don’t believe an act as important as learning to respect the country we live in should be reduced to a performative routine.
Rick Fabrro is a retired educator who has had a long career in public education as a counsellor, learning assistance teacher, English teacher, vice-principal, principal and assistant superintendent. He is also a past president of the Surrey Principals’ and Vice-Principals’ Association.


